What Cyber Insurance Costs a $40M Online Retailer: A Hypothetical Quote, Line by Line
A $40M online merchant selling into several countries might expect a landed cyber program cost of roughly $75K–$140K. Here's a hypothetical quote broken out line by line, with what moves each number.
Why the headline premium is the wrong number to compare
If you're a finance or risk lead at an online retailer with about $40M in revenue, the first cyber quote you see will probably show one premium. That figure tells you little. Cyber insurance cost for e-commerce businesses is set by a handful of lines most proposals bury: how much of the tower is primary and how much is excess, the sublimit on PCI fines and assessments, how business interruption treats your peak trading weeks, the retention you chose, how your broker is paid, and the premium taxes in each country where the policy is booked.
Two quotes can both say "$50,000" and still differ by $20,000 or more in what you pay, or by seven figures in what the policy pays back after a Black Friday outage. Below we build one hypothetical quote for a fictional merchant and price each line using typical 2026 market ranges. None of these figures is a real insurer's quote. Use them to decide which questions to ask, then confirm actual numbers with your broker and carriers.
The hypothetical merchant underwriters are pricing
Our example is a direct-to-consumer apparel and home goods brand. This is the profile an underwriter would see on the submission:
- Revenue: $40M a year, about 90% online. Customers are in the UK (40%), the EU (30%), North America (20%) and Australia (10%).
- Seasonality: about 35% of revenue lands in October to December. Black Friday week runs at roughly three times an average week.
- Payments: around 500,000 card transactions a year through a hosted checkout from a major processor. Card data is tokenized, so the merchant's own PCI scope is small.
- Infrastructure: a hosted e-commerce platform, a cloud-based ERP and a third-party logistics warehouse. The merchant depends heavily on vendors it doesn't control.
- Controls: MFA on email, remote access and admin consoles; endpoint detection and response (EDR) on every laptop; offline or immutable backups for the ERP; a tested incident response plan.
- Structure: a UK parent with an EU subsidiary and a small US entity.
That's a fairly clean risk. A merchant without MFA on its storefront admin, or one that stores card data itself, would be quoted very differently, and some carriers would decline it outright.
Primary premium and the excess layer
Merchants of this size commonly buy somewhere between $3M and $10M of total limit. We'll assume $10M: a $5M primary policy plus a $5M excess layer above it. Splitting the tower often costs less than one $10M primary, and it spreads your reliance across more than one carrier.
Primary ($5M limit, $50K retention): typical 2026 ranges for this profile run about $38,000 to $70,000. For the worked example we'll use $48,000. Where you land depends on control maturity, how many personal records you hold, what share of customers are in the US (where privacy class-action exposure is higher), and your claims history.
Excess ($5M xs $5M): excess layers are usually priced as a fraction of the primary premium, often around 50% to 75%, because a loss is less likely to reach that layer. Call it $26,000 here, within a typical range of $18,000 to $40,000.
Before comparing excess quotes, check whether the excess policy "follows form" to the primary. If the excess carrier adds its own exclusions, such as a narrower war or infrastructure wording, the cheaper layer may not respond to the very losses that exhaust your primary.
PCI fines and assessments coverage: the sublimit that gets missed
After a card data breach, the card brands can levy fines and assessments through your acquiring bank. These can include fraud recovery charges, reimbursement of card reissuance costs, and forensic investigation fees. Your merchant agreement usually passes them straight to you. Most cyber policies cover them, but under a sublimit, a smaller cap inside the overall limit.
Sublimits between $250,000 and $1M are common for PCI fines and assessments coverage. Our hypothetical primary includes $500,000. Raising it to $1M might add $3,000 to $6,000. We'll use $4,000.
Is it worth it? Tokenized hosted checkout lowers both the chance and the likely size of a card breach, which argues for staying at $500K. The counterargument is that skimming scripts injected into checkout pages can still expose card data in some setups, and a card population from 500,000 transactions a year is large enough that assessments could pass $500K. Our view: at this volume, buy the higher sublimit if it costs less than about 10% of the primary premium. Here it's roughly 8%.
Read the wording too. Some policies cover the assessment but not the processor's own fees. Others require that your PCI compliance was current when the breach happened.
Cyber business interruption for online stores in peak season
For an online retailer, business interruption is usually the largest realistic loss, bigger than breach response. The policy pays lost net profit plus continuing fixed costs while systems are down, and the fine print decides what that's worth in November.
Here's the rough math for our merchant. Q4 revenue of about $14M works out to around $150,000 a day on average. Black Friday week, at three times an average week, runs nearer $330,000 a day. A seven-day storefront outage then means roughly $2.3M of revenue. At a 40% gross margin that's about $900,000 of lost gross profit, before counting customers who don't come back. Policies measure loss as net profit plus continuing costs rather than gross margin, but the figure is a fair order of magnitude. Check these lines:
- Waiting period: 8 to 12 hours is common. A 24-hour waiting period in peak week could cost you tens of thousands of dollars of recovery, since a peak day is worth well over $100,000 in gross profit.
- Period of restoration: look for 120 to 180 days, so Q4 sales that slip into the new year are still inside the period.
- Dependent (contingent) BI: covers outages at your e-commerce platform, cloud host, payment processor or logistics provider. It's often sublimited to $250K to $1M, and some policies cover only malicious vendor events, not system failures. Lifting dependent BI to $2M and adding system-failure cover might cost $2,000 to $6,000. We'll use $3,500.
- Seasonality wording: the loss calculation should refer to comparable prior trading periods, not the 12-month average. Otherwise a December loss is calculated as if it happened in February.
Of all the buy-ups here, dependent BI deserves the closest look. A merchant running on third-party platforms carries most of its outage risk at its vendors.
Retention options and what each step buys
Underwriters will usually quote several retention levels. A higher retention lowers premium, but the savings shrink at each step. BI often carries a time-based retention (the waiting period) in addition to the dollar amount.
| Retention (hypothetical) | Primary premium (indicative) | Saving vs. $25K | Extra risk retained |
|---|---|---|---|
| $25,000 | $52,000 | None | None |
| $50,000 | $48,000 | About $4,000 | $25,000 per claim |
| $100,000 | $42,000 | About $10,000 | $75,000 per claim |
| $250,000 | $36,000 | About $16,000 | $225,000 per claim |
The decision rule: divide the premium saving by the extra risk you'd retain. Moving from $25K to $50K saves $4,000 for $25,000 of added exposure, a 16% "rate." That's often a reasonable trade for a merchant this size. Going to $250K saves only about 7 cents per extra dollar retained, and one serious incident would wipe out many years of savings. For most $40M merchants, $50K is the sensible middle. Go to $100K only if the CFO would be comfortable writing a check of that size at short notice in peak season.
Broker fees, premium taxes and the landed total
Two more lines turn the premium into what you actually pay.
Broker compensation
In many markets, broker commission is built into the premium, often around 10% to 20%. For accounts this size, some brokers instead charge a fee, either replacing commission or alongside a reduced one, typically $5,000 to $15,000. Neither model is wrong. Insist on written disclosure so you can compare a quote with commission built in against one with a separate fee. In our example the broker charges a $7,500 fee on a reduced-commission basis.
Premium taxes by region
Taxes depend on where the risk and the insured entities sit, not where the insurer is. Examples to confirm against current rates: the UK charges Insurance Premium Tax at 12%; Germany's insurance tax is 19%; India applies 18% GST to premiums; the UAE applies 5% VAT; Australia layers 10% GST with state stamp duty. In the US, admitted policies include tax in the rate, while non-admitted placements carry surplus lines taxes and fees that are usually a few percent and vary by state. Because our merchant has UK, EU and US entities, the broker should allocate premium across them, and each allocation is taxed locally.
| Line | Typical 2026 range | Worked example |
|---|---|---|
| Primary $5M, $50K retention | $38,000–$70,000 | $48,000 |
| PCI sublimit buy-up to $1M | $3,000–$6,000 | $4,000 |
| Dependent BI buy-up to $2M | $2,000–$6,000 | $3,500 |
| Excess $5M xs $5M | $18,000–$40,000 | $26,000 |
| Broker fee | $0–$15,000 | $7,500 |
| Premium taxes (blended, allocation-dependent) | 3%–19% of premium | About $9,800 |
| Landed total | Roughly $75,000–$140,000 for comparable profiles | About $98,800 |
In the example, taxes are about 12% of the $81,500 premium, because most of it is allocated to the UK parent. The total range is a judgment for comparable merchants, not the sum of every column's extremes. All figures are hypothetical and vary by contract and carrier.
What moves each line, and the red flags in your own quote
Controls move the price most. Missing MFA on remote access or storefront admin accounts commonly leads to a decline, or to ransomware cover that's sublimited or carries coinsurance. Strong EDR, immutable backups and tokenized checkout can pull a merchant toward the bottom of the primary range. Customer location matters too: a heavier US share tends to raise privacy liability pricing. Whether regulatory fines, such as those under GDPR, are insurable at all depends on local law, which is why policies cover them only "where insurable by law."
When real quotes arrive, watch for these red flags:
- Dependent BI that covers malicious events only, or is capped below what a peak-week outage would cost you.
- BI waiting periods over 12 hours, or loss calculations based on annual averages.
- An excess layer that doesn't follow form to the primary.
- PCI or social engineering fraud sublimits that appear only in an endorsement, not on the declarations page.
- Broker compensation that isn't stated, or taxes shown as "to be advised."
Your next step: before renewal, give your broker your Q4 daily revenue, gross margin and a list of critical vendors. Ask for quotes at two retention levels, with the PCI and dependent BI buy-ups priced separately. Then judge each option on landed cost against your largest realistic peak-season loss, not the headline premium. Have a licensed broker or coverage counsel review the final wording before you bind.
Quick answers
What is a realistic cyber insurance premium for a retailer with $40M in revenue?
For a $5M primary limit with good controls, typical 2026 ranges are roughly $38,000 to $70,000. A $10M program with taxes and fees might land around $75,000 to $140,000. Weak controls, card data stored on your own systems, or a large US customer base push toward the top of that range or beyond. Confirm actual pricing with your broker, because it varies widely by carrier and contract.
Does cyber insurance cover PCI fines and assessments?
Most cyber policies do, but usually under a sublimit of $250,000 to $1M rather than the full policy limit. Coverage may require that you were PCI compliant at the time of the breach, and some wordings exclude the processor's own fees. Ask for the sublimit amount and the exact wording before you bind.
How do cyber insurance sublimits affect what I can actually recover?
A sublimit caps a specific type of loss inside the overall limit. With a $5M policy and a $500K dependent BI sublimit, you can recover no more than $500K for an outage at your e-commerce platform, whatever the actual loss. Sublimits are sometimes listed in endorsements rather than on the declarations page, so ask your broker for a complete schedule.
Is a higher retention a good way to cut cyber premium?
Up to a point. Moving from a $25K to a $50K retention often saves a meaningful share of premium, but further increases usually save much less for each extra dollar you take on. Choose the highest retention your company could pay quickly, including in peak season, without straining cash flow.
Written by the Breachnodeops editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.